Customer Reviews: Read 12 more reviews...
 If you enjoy Erikson, think twice before buying, June 28, 2008
Andrew Antony Ewing (UK)
1 out of 3 found this review helpful
Upfront I'll confess to being an unashamed fan of Erikson's writing and believe he is one of a small group of writers that have single handed resuscitated the Fantasy literature market. And given this rich, diverse and deep universe he has unfolded, then the concept of another writer taking an aspect of the story line - in this case a kind of prelude - seems valid. Unlike other critics noted, I revel in the complexity of Erikson's writing; simply because he is not creating complexity as a kind of 'Oh look how abstract and contorted I can make the plot lines' but more that he makes it look so easy; sort of Robert Ludlum meets Terry Pratchett - rich, engaging characters, amusing and intelligent dialogue, innovative magic and civilisation concepts.
Therefore... this book reflect against that is plodding, single dimensional with characters that lack the Erikson whit and colour. I also think that given Erikson's books to date have always debut as soft cover, making this derivative work appear as hardcover (though I notice Toll Of Hounds is hardcover) was a poor business decision by the publishers. I think I'll steer clear of the rest of Mr Esslemonts work.
 Nah... June 24, 2008
Flemming Nielsen (Denmark)
I bought this book because I'm a big fan of Erikson's writing. In spite of the somewhat lukewarm reviews it had had, I was hoping Night of Knives would be a fairly decent book, adding to the already immense history of the Malazan world. Sadly the book didn't really deliver. Yes, there was a bit more detail about the fall of the emperor and so forth, and a few cool(-ish) references to some of the nastier and lesser known denizens of the Malazan world, but overall, the story was messy and seems to have been part of a larger story. There seems to be an underlying assumption that the readers know more about the situation in which the story takes place, than we are actually told. On several occasions, this leaves us wondering what just happened.
I'm probably getting Esslemont's next book as well, but then I am a bit of a completist. I can tell you though, that I would not have gotten very involved in the Malazan world had I read Esslemont before I read Erikson.
 A great addition to everything Malaz June 1, 2008
Mr. D. Peedell (Bampton, Oxfordshire United Kingdom)
5 out of 6 found this review helpful
I would have given this 4 stars normally, but there is always some idiot that gives one star and an explantion like 'I thought this was a book about knives'. Contrary to the said one star review, you could easily read this stand alone, I will admit that reading GOTM first may make it more enjoyable, but there is more about Daseem in Erikson's later novels.
I am look forward to Return of the Crimson Guard.
A great beginning May 18, 2008
Adam Foster (Helsinki, Finland)
4 out of 5 found this review helpful
The Malazan world certainly is deep enough to support two writers, and I was delighted to find this book as enthralling as Erikson's earlier work. The style is different, but equally good and more suited to the presentation of a tighter storyline. I cannot say whether it works without being familiar with the others books, but if you like great writing and don't mind your brain working while reading, just get this along with as many of Erikson's books you can fit on your shelf.
Appendix A May 15, 2008
J.Yasimoto (Essex)
3 out of 4 found this review helpful
Like it or not, this book will be seen as a supplement to Erikson's books. Nothing more. I must confess during the last few years I've been constantly tempted to throw the Malazan books away in disgust. I like to know what's going on and these books are... difficult to say the least. The only reason I keep reading is the quality of the writing. It's almost poetic. And always delivered with a knowing, almost sarcastic, raised eyebrow.
This book has none of that. The writing is workmanlike. But it's quite easy to get through. Only 450 odd pages of large text. If you've never read one of the main Malazan books start with Gardens of the Moon. But if you've read the main sequence and are hungry for more, you can't go too far wrong with this chapter. Just remember to think of it as "Appendix A".
|
